Legal action

Helping disabled tenants to make reasonable adjustments to their homes

Published: 4 December 2018

Last updated: 30 January 2019

What countries does this apply to?

Case details

Protected Characteristic Disability
Types of equality claim Direct discrimination, Harassment, Reasonable adjustments, Victimisation
Court or tribunal County Court
Decision has to be followed in England, Wales
Law applies in England, Wales
Case state Concluded
Our involvement Legal assistance (section 28 of the Equality Act 2006)
Outcome Judgment
Areas of life Living standards, Participation
International framework Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD)

Case name: Andrew Smailes, Stacey Poyner-Smailes and Clewer Court Residents Ltd

A disabled woman needed to make reasonable adjustments to her home, but because she was renting, they were refused by the landlord. We successfully funded this case to clarify whether a term in the lease prohibiting alterations is contrary to the Equality Act. 

Background

Mrs Smailes has a physical disability which restricts her mobility. 

She and her husband bought the leasehold of a flat. The property needed to be substantially adapted to accommodate her needs as a disabled person. 

A term in the lease prohibited physical alterations to the premises and the landlord refused permission to make the alterations.

Why we were involved

We wanted to clarify the law as to whether a term in the lease prohibiting alterations is contrary to the Equality Act. 

This comes within our core objective which is to uphold the system of equality and human rights protections.

What we did

We provided legal assistance for Mrs Smailes. 

What happened

The case was successful. Cardiff County Court ruled that a landlord acted unlawfully by refusing to allow Mrs Smailes to make necessary adaptations to her home. 

The Smailes were awarded substantial damages. 

Who will benefit

This ruling helps to protect disabled tenants.

It compels landlords to change a prohibition against alteration in order to enable a disabled tenant to make alterations so as to avoid a substantial disadvantage.

Date of hearing

4 December 2018

Date concluded

30 January 2019

Page updates

Advice and support

If you think you might have been treated unfairly and want further advice, you can contact the Equality Advisory and Support Service (EASS).

The EASS is an independent advice service, not operated by the Equality and Human Rights Commission.

Phone: 0808 800 0082
 

Or email using the contact form on the EASS website.
phone icon

Call the EASS on:

0808 800 0082