Legal action
Can parents give consent for the living arrangements of older teenagers who cannot give consent themselves?
Published: 3 October 2022
Last updated: 3 October 2022
What countries does this apply to?
Case details
Protected Characteristic | Age, Disability |
---|---|
Types of equality claim | Other |
Court or tribunal | Supreme Court |
Decision has to be followed in | England, Wales |
Law applies in | England, Scotland, Wales |
Case state | Concluded |
Our involvement | Intervention (section 30 of the Equality Act 2006) |
Outcome | Judgment |
Areas of life | Health, Living standards |
Human Rights law | Article 5: Right to liberty and security |
International framework | Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD), Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) |
Case name: In the matter of D (A Child)
D has ADHD, Asperger's, Tourette's and mild learning disability.
At the age of 16 D was placed in confined in a residential unit by the local authority, with their parents’ consent.
Legal issue
When a child aged 16 or 17 lacks capacity to consent to their living arrangements, what happens when they are placed in local authority residential care? Can a parent consent on their behalf? If they can then there is no need for the local authority to seek judicial authority for the placement. If there is no consent then Article 5(1) would be invoked as this would constitute deprivation of liberty.
Why we were involved
We work to make sure equality and human rights standards are respected by the rules and practice governing entry into, exit from and treatment in institutions.
What we did
We intervened in the case using our powers under section 30 of the Equality Act 2006.
What happened
We intervened in this case, arguing that placing D in confinement was depriving them of their liberty. The Court agreed and held by a majority that parents cannot consent to the confinement of a 16/17 year old child, even if they lack capacity to consent for themselves.
Who will benefit
Very shortly after the hearing the Government wrote to the Court to inform them they were amending the Mental Capacity (Amendment) Bill (now the MC(A)Act 2019) which was passing through Parliament, to extend Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards to 16/17 year olds.
While this was pre-judgment it appears likely that the appeal influenced this amendment and it therefore had significant practical impact.
Date of hearing
Page updates
Published:
3 October 2022
Last updated:
3 October 2022